Hawaii Canada California California California Texas Texas Texas

A Classical Conversation

Join the conversation! An eclectic group of folks have joined in to carry out the classical conversation; some of these folks may share or represent views we don't hold. We need them to be dialectic and have a classical conversation, and they need us too! So thanks for being patient with us and our fellow participants.

Why Adam is Foundational to Medicine

Posted by Jonathan Bartlett
Jonathan Bartlett
Jonathan Bartlett is the director of The Blyth Institute, a nonprofit organizati
User is currently offline
on Tuesday, 18 October 2011
in Articles

We have all heard about the story of Adam and Eve from the Bible. God creates Adam, then Eve, then they sin, and the whole world falls apart. All creation groans. A great flood rips the world apart. Humanity is left broken in a broken world.

This story is derided by many people in the modern world as being a fantasy, or, at best, an epic tail from an ancient people. They say that if it serves any purpose at all, it is as a morality tale or as a theological allegory about the nature of God.

However, it is interesting how much modern medicine relies on the story of Adam and Eve. Now, most people practicing medicine would deny this. I would argue that they rely on the reality of Adam without realizing it in almost every decision they make.

Jason Lisle has argued that people misunderstand the difference between "shared ground" and "neutral ground" when it comes to our basic assumptions. Christians and non-Christians do indeed have a whole lot of "shared ground" with unbelievers with regard to  our basic assumptions. However, while the ground is shared with non-believers, it is definitely not neutral. The base assumptions of medicine are grounded in a Christian conception of humanity, founded upon the history of Adam and the fall. Even if a medical practitioner does not believe in Adam and Eve, his practice of medicine is grounded on them.

How so?

Medicine (and in fact all of biology) operates on the assumption that there is a regularized biological design behind humanity. The categories "sick" and "well" are only meaningful in reference to an ideal of perfection. Without that ideal, there is no "sick" and no "well,” and certainly no such thing as "healing.” The idea of "healing" is a return to wholeness. What is wholeness or wellness if we do not have a referent for what being whole is? How would we determine sickness if there were not some ideal we were seeking?

Those who have thrown off their Christian heritage more fully might say that medicine is not about "healing" per se, but rather about making us feel better or perform better. It is a simply a case of doctors helping us achieve our personal goals, without any reference to a perfected ideal. However, if that were the case, then we would expect our doctors to prescribe us steroids if we wanted to play baseball, cocaine if we wanted to work at all hours of the night, and vodka if we were depressed.

Why are these behaviors criticized by doctors? Because wellness is not about just getting what we want, it is about returning to the original wholeness that God designed. Steroids enhance performance, but they do  so at opposing angles to God's design. Cocaine will certainly help us stay awake, but it leads to a life out-of-balance with our nature. Vodka might make us forget our worries, but it does so by removing the faculties with which God blessed us.

Therefore, medicine is coherent as an enterprise because of the notion that there was, at one time, an Adam—a perfect human archetype. In addition, we are not models of this perfection ourselves because of the biblical fall. Therefore, medicine attempts to restore, as closely as possible, each person into the originally designed wholeness of life. That only makes sense if there is an original design in which we are not fully participating.

Therefore, whether doctors believe in Adam or not, the way that they approach their medical vocation demonstrates their reliance upon Adam. The worldview which undergirds the entire enterprise of medicine is not the lab tests and medical guidelines, but rather the yearning of God's creation to return to the system which He designed for us, and against which we first rebelled.

0 votes
Jonathan Bartlett is the director of The Blyth Institute, a nonprofit organization dedicated to research and education in biology. Jonathan started in computer science, both programming and writing about computer science topics. His first book, Programming from the Ground Up, has been used at schools ranging as far as Princeton and DeVry. He also wrote a number of papers for IBM’s DeveloperWorks on technical computer science issues.

Jonathan’s interest in biology came from his family’s battle with genetic illnesses. While studying about genetic illnesses, Jonathan realized the tremendous overlap between computer science and biology, and how much the design patterns that are regularly used in computer science can contribute to understanding how the genome works. Toward this end, Jonathan started The Blyth Institute, and has published several papers on showing how design thinking can relate to the genome.

Jonathan recently released the book MicroSecession: Simple Ways to Liberate Yourself, Your Family, and Your Community from Government Idiocy. The book focuses on community independence, independent living, and creating value in your home that is independent of money.

Jonathan and his wife Christa have been homeschooling their children for several years, and love being a part of the Classical Conversations community. Christa teaches in the Classical Conversations Challenge program.


Most Popular

I need to tell a story, a true story from our own history. This story will help us to answer some questions we have about the content which we use t
For as he thinketh in his heart, so is he…     — Proverbs 23:7     All of my children are in the double digits. While
Chapters Six through Eight - Math, Geography, and Logic   What’s Your Big Hairy Monster? by Cara McLauchlan     “Teach your stu
As I have visited with parents over the years about the classical, Christian model of education, many have been overwhelmed by what seems to be “way
As a young Christian, I studied the book of James intently. As a matter of fact, the first verses of any length that I ever really memorized were fr

Home | FAQ | Request a Catalog | Online Catalog | Conference Schedule | Online Bookstore | Merchandise and Gifts | Our Partners | Store Return Policy | Contact Us | Leigh Bortins | Faith Statement |
Press Room | New Classical Portal | CC Webmail | Articles | Product Submission Guidelines | Advertisers | Employment | Menu for Tablet Users

©1997-2013 Classical Conversations Inc.
PO Box 909, West End, NC 27376